DIY Exterior Trim Board Replacement

Peak Pro Painting • September 4, 2017

Are you thinking of painting the exterior of your home but are in need of repairs that can’t (and shouldn’t) be covered by a fresh coat of paint? A great place to start, is to check the exterior trim of your home! Maybe the wear and tear is visible to the common onlooker, or maybe the damage is hiding under paint. Always make sure to check your home for exterior trim damage. That way your new paint job isn’t at risk of bubbling, peeling, or molding from water creeping under the paint of your home.  

Where to Look

Before you start painting the exterior of your home check the exterior trim around your home for cracks, holes, loose, damaged or rotting wood. Trim is typically a decorative piece of your home that can be found around windows, doors under gutters, under the roof, and virtually anywhere the exterior would need to repel water from entering your home. Rotting wood is not always visible to the naked eye, make sure to feel the exterior trim on your home, looking for soft and squishy wood. Painting over rotted wood can happen if you’re not careful, and will cause you more problems in the future if it isn’t replaced promptly. Trim board replacement can be simple. Below are some tips to help you with your  exterior trim board replacement project.

Find a perfect match

If possible, it is always a good idea to take a piece of the old board with you to the lumber store to get the best match. However if the wood is rotten and you are unable to extract it all in one piece, take good measurements. Measure exactly how long the board is so that you’re not making extra trips to the store. And save the hassle and measure twice before cutting. When cutting, using a miter saw, it will ensure you have perfectly straight lines and perfect measurements.

Replacing Exterior Trim Board

 Luckily not all damaged trim boards need replacement, sometimes it’s as easy as adding a nail and re-caulking the exterior trim to the siding! However in some cases, like rotting wood, it’s best to replace the entire trim board, and sometimes the entire exterior trim around a window or door. There are plenty of tools you can use for this job, you can remove the damaged trim by using a pry bar, screwdriver or the claw of a hammer. First you will want to remove old caulking with a box cutter or sturdy putty knife. Next you will want to begin pulling out the nails (this may require puncturing the rotted wood and digging it out if the wood is unsalvageable). In most cases -if the wood is not too rotten- you can leverage the wood with a pry bar or the back of a hammer until you have fully extracted your exterior trim board. Make sure when you are pulling up the trim that you do not dent any of the siding in the process.  

Caulk

Caulk and paint your new exterior trim board right away. You do not want your new wood exposed to water or vulnerable to further damage.

 

Ready to work with Peak Pro Painting?

Let's connect! We’re here to help.

Send us a message and we’ll be in touch. 

Or give us a call today at 720-399-7325

Agency Contact Form

More Painting Tips, Hacks and Suggestions

March 23, 2026
If you’re looking to get the most out of your exterior stain, try using a solid stain instead of semi-transparent. It looks similar to a paint but it doesn’t go on as thick. Solid stains still show a little of the wood grain but do cover mostly like a paint. You’ll get more life out of solid stain. It also saves you money!
March 23, 2026
Sherwin Williams is always coming out with beautiful colors that we love!! One newer color by Sherwin Williams is Amazing Gray. It’s a nice warm gray that goes good with a lot of different accent colors and of course flat white ceilings. Let our expert residential painters for more information and a quote.
March 23, 2026
Most paints on the market now are low VOC and were seeing more and more ZERO VOC paints hit the market. We recommend ZERO VOC inside your home when there is a pregnant woman, a baby in the house or small children. Ask your rep if VOC is recommended in your home. Let our expert residential painters for more information and a quote.
By Peak Pro Painting April 24, 2020
Safety is the number one priority of Peak Pro Painting during the COVID19 Pandemic. What we are promising to our staff, as well as to the homeowners that we are privileged to work with: We will maintain social distancing in the office as well as when in public. No handshaking or physical touching needs to take […] The post How We Handle Our Customers’ Safety appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
The post How to Perform Exterior Staining appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
The post How To Paint a Stained Interior Railing appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
The post How To Perform Exterior Brick Painting appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
On most homes there will be three different colors for the body, trim, and accent. Depending on the layout of your home there may be an option to use two different colors for the body. As you can see above a tan and brown were used in tandem to color the body. This dual-body color […] The post More Than One Body Color – Lakewood, Colorado appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
If you’re having trouble deciding on a color for your home, it may help to think of the overall build and theme of your home.  Stucco homes typically have a more western feel to their architecture including the roofing tiles are made of clay, a very western building material. Tans and browns compliment this architectural […] The post Exterior Painting Color Scheme Choices – Commerce City, Colorado appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.
By Peak Pro Painting April 7, 2020
Using a bold color on the body of your home can be a gamble, but if its use is done correctly the end effect can be stunning! The dark brown plays nicely with the medium tan color of the bricks. To soften the darker colors Peak Pro Painting would always suggest using a bright white […] The post Bold Exterior Painting Colors – Highlands Ranch, Colorado appeared first on Peak Professional Painting.